WELL, WOULD YOU LOOK AT THAT.
West Michigan really showed up for the ultimate engagement ring showdown, and honestly? You understood the assignment. Over 2,000 votes came flying in faster than a girl’s new fiancé realizes she’s already planned every detail of their wedding… and life together.
(Yes, including the dog’s name, the honeymoon playlist, and where they’re retiring at 65.)
We’re talkin’ romantic three-stone stunners. Bold bezel-set beauties. And enough strong opinions to make a bridal stylist blush. You didn’t hold back—and we love you for it.
As your friendly neighborhood jeweler in Hudsonville, we live for this kind of thing: the love stories, the “ooh THAT one,” the gasps, the group chats, the “accidental” screenshots.
So! Without further delay (or drumroll—we know you’re already scrolling), here they are:
The Top 10 Engagement Rings West Michigan is absolutely obsessed with.
🥇 1 The Three-Stone Oval Engagement Ring
West Michigan voted in droves (2,000+ of you!), and this beauty stole the show like the lead in a Hallmark Christmas movie.
The Three-Stone Oval Engagement Ring is everything.
She’s elegant. She’s timeless. She’s that rare mix of “classic” and “you’ve never seen anything quite like it.”
So what made her the favorite?
The Oval Center Stone – A graceful 1.5 carat stunner that flatters the finger and catches the light just right.
Petite Side Stones – Two round diamonds that add the perfect hint of sparkle without stealing the spotlight.
The Yellow Gold Band – 14K of warm, golden glow that makes every ring selfie look like it belongs in a bridal magazine.
The Six Claw Prongs – Delicate but strong—like every great love story.
🥈 2 The Bezel Set Emerald Engagement Ring
West Michigan showed up in style—and the Emerald Cut Bezel Set Solitaire Engagement Ring wasn’t just a runner-up, it was a total scene-stealer.
This ring? She’s cool, calm, collected. The kind that walks in, says one thing, and suddenly owns the room.
So what made her stand out?
The Emerald Cut Center Stone – 2 carats of clean, confident sparkle with main character energy.
The Bezel Setting – Sleek. Secure. Practically dares you to take your eyes off it.
The Cathedral Design – A subtle lift that says, “Yes, I have presence.”
The Yellow Gold Band – Warm, rich, and quietly bold—like golden hour, but on your finger.
🥉 3 The White Gold Oval Solitaire Engagement Ring
West Michigan clearly has a thing for ovals—because this Oval Solitaire in White Gold glided into third place like it was born to be there.
This ring is simple, but never boring. It’s the classic you think you’ve seen before—until you see it on your hand and suddenly everything else looks… extra.
So what made her shine?
The Oval Diamond – Elegant and flattering with just the right touch of drama.
The White Gold Band – Cool-toned, polished, and modern without trying too hard.
The Sleek Solitaire Setting – No distractions. Just that one perfect stone, front and center.
The Clean Cathedral Profile – Subtle height that gives it presence without being flashy.
The Final Cut: Rounding Out West Michigan’s Top 10 Favorite Engagement Rings
Of course, narrowing it down to just one favorite wasn’t easy—and the rest of the top 10 brought the sparkle, the style, and some serious personality. From the vintage-glam vibes of the Mosaic Halo to the romantic asymmetry of the Toi Et Moi, every ring on this list earned its spot. Whether you love a Shared Prong that twinkles from every angle, or a Pear Solitaire that dares to be different, there’s a ring here that’s ready to turn heads. Want something playful? Try the Scattered Diamond. Classic with a twist? The Spaced Diamond is calling.
There’s something for every style, every story, and every “that’s the one” moment.
| Rank | Engagement Ring | Ring Style | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| 🥇 1 |
|
Three-Stone Oval Engagement Ring | View Ring |
| 🥈 2 |
|
Bezel Set Emerald Engagement Ring | View Ring |
| 🥉 3 |
|
White Gold Oval Solitaire | View Ring |
| 4 |
|
Cluster Diamond Engagement Ring | View Ring |
| 5 |
|
Shared Prong Engagement Ring | View Ring |
| 6 |
|
Spaced Diamond Engagement Ring | View Ring |
| 7 |
|
Scattered Diamond Engagement Ring | View Ring |
| 8 |
|
Mosaic Diamond Halo Engagement Ring | View Ring |
| 9 |
|
Pear Solitaire | View Ring |
| 10 |
|
Toi Et Moi | View Ring |
And there you have it—West Michigan’s most-loved engagement rings, voted on by actual humans with excellent taste (ahem, you). Whether one totally stole your heart or you’re still torn between a few favorites, here’s the truth: no amount of scrolling beats slipping a ring on your finger and feeling that feeling.
So come on in. Try them on. Bring your best friend, your mom, or just that screenshot you’ve been staring at since Tuesday.
Or book a try-on session—because the best way to find your ring is to feel it.
We’ll be here, cheering you on and making you a fancy coffee while you find the ring of your dreams.
